Not dead – just disappointing

Posted on 7 July 2014 in Root Systems,

At Trees Impact we persistently push the ‘quality’ message.  (eg see Why Buy Only the Best Trees Available).   But preach as much as we like, decision-makers actually need to see what we are talking about to appreciate that message.  So…

Here are some pictures worth a thousand words…

This subdivision was originally planted about eight years ago with Tuckeroos at quite advanced sizes (estimated to be 300 litres).  Some have since died and been removed.  Some survivors look reasonable, others lack foliage and vigour – but not one has grown into a handsome,stable tree.
What we have today is a streetscape that is very disappointing, with trees that will never achieve the designer’s expectations.  When you also consider that this site has good soil and high rainfall, the poor outcome is doubly disappointing.  And this is not a ‘one off’.  It is to be seen time and time again.

"Original Tree 1" shows a tree that is alive, probably smaller than it was when originally planted, with a very sparse crown and poor vigour.
"Original Tree 2" shows a tree that appears to be in better condition. However, much of this denser, more vigorous foliage is the result of and supported by sucker growth - not the original trunk.
"Original Tree 3" Shows a tree with a small clump of healthy foliage occurring on the unbalanced remains of the crown following considerable dieback.
This excellent "Replacement Tree" is a Trees Impact Tuckeroo - planted at a 200 litre size and given a reasonable but not excessive amount of watering during its establishment just two years ago. It was planted as replacement for a very poor original specimen (similar to the others in the same street).


It should come as no surprise to learn that when the original tree was removed its root system was found to be seriously girdled (see Its All in the Roots ).  While all trees may have presented well at planting, their significant root defects meant that the whole planting was doomed to always look sad.  What a disappointing waste of money and opportunity.

Imagine how well established this streetscape would now be if all trees had been planted at a Trees Impact (NATSPEC) standard eight or nine years ago.

Ignoring quality for the sake of price always has been and remains a false economy.

Copyright © 2013-2019 Trees Impact Pty Limited, all rights reserved
Material on this site is subject to copyright under Australian law and other intellectual property protection. Trees Impact Pty Limited claims ownership of the copyright in the information and material provided on this site, unless stated otherwise. Material on or accessible through this site may not be copied or used for any commercial purpose, sale or further dissemination (except as legally allowed for private use) without the written permission of Trees Impact Pty Limited.

While Trees Impact Pty Limited has attempted to make the information on this website and its downloadable content as accurate as possible, that information and the opinions expressed are intended to be informative or to stimulate thought and discussion only and are provided in good faith without any express or implied warranty. There is no guarantee given as to the accuracy or currency of any of the information and Trees Impact Pty Limited does not accept responsibility for any loss or damage occasioned to any party by use of the information contained on or accessed through this site.

Related Articles

Why Buy Only the Best Available Trees?  For the Following 5 Reasons.

Posted on 5 June 2013 in

To buy 'cheaper' trees in the hope of saving money is a false economy. As with all things, better quality means greater reliability and reliability will always reduce expenses and risk...... Keep reading

It’s all in the roots!

Posted on 27 March 2014 in

Beware of container-grown trees? Well, be alert but not alarmed. When trees with girdled roots are planted the visual, environmental and social benefits are all compromised.... Keep reading

Make Sure Your New Trees Thrive

Posted on 22 July 2013 in

After being planted (carefully), the single most important need of a newly-planted tree is to receive adequate moisture.... Keep reading